For topic:

Reward is a feature that we hope will inspire experts to answer important questions and make their answers available to everyone. It allows a sponsor to signal that they think a question is particularly important by offering a financial prize for established arguments that contribute to the establishment or refutation of the topic. A prize winner can keep the money, apply it to reward other questions, or donate it to charity.

Reward Name :
Reward Description:
Prize:
Closing Date:
Status:

Payout Rules:
The total reward is divided among all statements that were created during the period after the reward is offered and are established at the payout date.

The total reward is divided among all save events occurring during the period after the reward is offered that add one or more statements that change the status of the root and are established at the payout date.

Half of the reward is divided among all statements that were created during the period after the reward is offered and are established at the payout date and the other half is divided among all save events occurring during the period after the reward is offered that add one or more statements that change the status of the root and are established at the payout date.



Topic:

Reward is a feature that we hope will inspire experts to answer important questions and make their answers available to everyone. It allows a sponsor to signal that they think a question is particularly important by offering a financial prize for established arguments that contribute to the establishment or refutation of the topic. A prize winner can keep the money, apply it to reward other questions, or donate it to charity.

Rewrd Name :
Reward Description:
Offered By:
Prize:
Closing Date:
Status:

Payout Rules:


Conditions:


Topic:

Reward is a feature that we hope will inspire experts to answer important questions and make their answers available to everyone. It allows a sponsor to signal that they think a question is particularly important by offering a financial prize for established arguments that contribute to the establishment or refutation of the topic. A prize winner can keep the money, apply it to reward other questions, or donate it to charity.

Test string

TOPIC HISTORY

GPS CSO radio sources are the progenitors of the large scale radio sources

CSO/GPS graph


Statements

Statement Type Title Description Proposed Probability Author History Last Updated
STATEMENT vlbi proper motions observed

Very long baseline interferometry observations show that the ends of the sources are moving outwards through the galactic interstellar medium at velocities of about 10% of the speed of light. Reference An & Baan 2012 http://adsabs.harvard.edu/abs/2012ApJ...760...77A

1.0 Chris O Details 2019-01-05 11:44:30.0
STATEMENT GPS/CSO radio sources are the progenitors of the large scale radio sources

GPS/CSO are small radio sources in the nuclei of galaxies. They are thought to grow into large radio sources which extend beyond their host galaxies into the intergalactic medium.  There is some evidence that at least some of these sources are not going to become large radio sources. 

1.0 Chris O Details 2018-12-07 06:15:07.0
STATEMENT Arguments in Favor 1.0 Chris O Details 2018-12-07 06:15:07.0
STATEMENT Arguments against 1.0 Chris O Details 2018-12-07 06:15:07.0
STATEMENT Too many GPS CSO sources

There are too many small sources compared to the extrapolation from the large sources (O'Dea & Baum 1997, http://adsabs.harvard.edu/abs/1997AJ....113..148O).  The "extra" small sources could be objects that remain small. 

1.0 Chris O Details 2018-12-07 06:15:07.0
STATEMENT Assume GPS sources live long enough

We assume that GPS/CSO sources have sufficient lifetimes (e.g. at least one million years) to grow to large size.  There is strong evidence that large radio sources live at least 10 million years (e.g., Parma et al. 1999,  http://adsabs.harvard.edu/abs/1999A%26A...344....7P).  However, it is not clear that the  sources that are observed to be small live that long. 

1.0 Chris O Details 2018-12-07 06:15:07.0
STATEMENT gps/css associated with star formation

Tadhunter et al 2011 http://adsabs.harvard.edu/abs/2011MNRAS.412..960T  found that GPS/CSS are more often in star forming galaxies than large radio galaxies.

The confimement of the sources by dense star formation regions may enhance radio power.

1.0 Chris O Details 2018-12-07 06:15:07.0
STATEMENT Assume confinement enhances radio power

The expansion of the radio source will reduce the energy of the radiating particles and thus reduce the luminosity. Confinement of the radio source will keep the radio emission brighter (e.g., Barthel & Arnaud 1996,  http://adsabs.harvard.edu/abs/1996MNRAS.283L..45B).

1.0 Chris O Details 2018-12-07 06:15:07.0
STATEMENT Assume signature of star formation lasts as long as radio galaxy lifetime

If the lifetime of the star formation is long compared to the radio source lifetime, then the lack of star formation in large radio sources compared to the small radio sources is significant. On the other hand, if the signatures of star formation are short lived (< 10 Myr), some large radio sources that were star forming then they were small have outlived the star formation episode. 

1.0 Chris O Details 2018-12-07 06:15:07.0